Civil Discourse
The current formula for political coverage can be defined in five steps:
1. declare controversial topic
2. extremist spouting off from one side
3. extremist spouting off from the other side
4. yell at each other for a while
5. conclude that the opposition is the devil's spawn
This brand of political discussion destroys meaningful civil discourse. It promotes toxic, unending disagreements. It promotes divisions and societal stagnation. But, no one can argue that the formula isn't solid gold for the talking heads and their media platforms.
Thoughtful political observers from past generations wouldn't last a minute on cable TV. Nor would they want to.
Mass media no more models healthy civil discourse than porn models healthy sexual behavior. But, for some reason, unlike porn, mass media political discourse is not recognized as being a cartoon of the real thing. This suggests that maybe we are losing sight of what civil discourse should be.
Effective civil discourse should point toward action and resolution of controversies. Pundits, of course, don't want resolution. Why would they? They make bank off the controversies, not solutions. But, citizens need resolution of controversies. Whether it is health care, immigration, homelessness, or education, people need solutions that work. We reach those solutions by considering options and picking the best ones. This requires patient conversations, thoughtful presentations, meaningful give and take, and the bridge building work of crafting consensus.
Don't get us wrong. Protests and volume are important parts of the political process. To advance a cause, citizens have to do what it takes to grab the microphone and be heard. But, what are we doing once we have the mic? With blogs and social media and a proliferation of channels and publications, it is easier than ever to be heard. That is good. But, are we saying things that are worth hearing? Are we listening to what others are saying? Are we working toward solutions?
The Utah Bee wants to promote conversations that move us away from the extremes and toward solutions and civil discourse. Please join in!